From overjoyed to deeply disappointed
What Works Well:
Clean Design: Job Boardly has a modern, sleek, and intuitive design that makes it pleasant to use for both admins and visitors.
Fast Loading: The platform is impressively fast, ensuring a smooth user experience.
Ease of Use: Building a job board is straightforward, even for non-technical users. The setup process is simple, and the interface is user-friendly.
Good Backend UX: Managing the job board from the admin panel feels intuitive and efficient. All necessary features are well-organized.
Areas for Improvement:
Sitemap Accessibility:
The sitemap.xml is inaccessible to search engine crawlers like Google and Bing due to a 403 error. This significantly hampers SEO, which is critical for a job board’s visibility.
Job Backfill Issues:
Backfill jobs do not align with the specified criteria. For instance, a tech-focused job board imported irrelevant listings (e.g., unrelated fields like childhood education). Out of 250 imported jobs, only 2 were relevant but still not a perfect match.
Fine-tuning of the backfill job algorithm to respect filters and categories is needed.
HTML Header Embedding:
The embedded HTML for compliance tools (like cookie tracking) is not functioning properly. This could be a compliance risk for some users, especially in regions with strict data protection laws.
Stripe and Affiliate Integration:
While Stripe integration works great, the lack of native affiliate program support is a downside. A guide or built-in feature for adding affiliate functionality would be valuable.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Fix the 403 error on the sitemap.xml to improve crawler access and SEO performance.
Enhance the job backfill feature to better respect the specified criteria and job titles.
Resolve issues with embedded HTML in headers, ensuring seamless integration with third-party tools.
Provide guidance or features for affiliate program integration, expanding monetization options for users.
Final Thoughts:
Job Boardly has a lot of potential with its excellent design and usability, but it faces significant functional challenges that could deter professional users who rely heavily on SEO, relevant job backfilling, and advanced integrations. With targeted improvements, it could become a top-tier platform for creating and managing job boards.
Kyle_JobBoardly
Nov 13, 2024Hi there! Thanks for the feedback and so sorry you were having issue with uploading your sitemap. There was indeed a bug that prevented them from being fetched for a few days. We have since resolved it so if you try uploading it again it should work now!
We totally agree, sitemaps are crucial and we urgently made moves to fix it. Thanks for bringing it up.
I'd love to see if I help with your backfillers if I can. Shoot an email to support and I'd be glad to help you out there and see if we can get them dialed in.
Thanks and we appreciate you 🙏